Opening Scene Preference
Posted: Thu Aug 25, 2005 11:22 am
Having now read the orginal script I am curious to know which of the three opening scenes you prefer.
Would you have liked to have seen Ajax working out on the beach and watch Swan showing of his knife skills. And how cool would it have been to see the Warriors march though the Mongols patch.
Or do you prefer the tv version with the daytime opening scene of Cleon talking to his girlfriend and then addressing each of the Warriors as to why they have been chosen.
Or do you prefer Walter Hill's decision that the film starts at night with the opening shot of the Wonder Wheel and the only day scene being at the end after their night of hell .
IMO I prefer the version which starts at night. I appreciate that without the daytime scenes it leaves some unanswered gaps in the film but I just think that the strength of the opening scene at night and the music just sets the pace for the whole film. When I watch the daytime version I just don't get that immediate impact and expectancy. I also just can't get over Cleon's dodgy hairstyle and think he should not be seen without his head scarf/piece. I also don't like the music that is played when the Warriors walk away as this music dates the film.
I'm interested to know what the film would have been like if they had stuck to the scripted version but for me I still think having the film start at night and immediately seeing some of the other gangs plus listening to the Warriors in pairs talking about the conclave was just the perfect start to a classic film.
What do you think???
Would you have liked to have seen Ajax working out on the beach and watch Swan showing of his knife skills. And how cool would it have been to see the Warriors march though the Mongols patch.
Or do you prefer the tv version with the daytime opening scene of Cleon talking to his girlfriend and then addressing each of the Warriors as to why they have been chosen.
Or do you prefer Walter Hill's decision that the film starts at night with the opening shot of the Wonder Wheel and the only day scene being at the end after their night of hell .
IMO I prefer the version which starts at night. I appreciate that without the daytime scenes it leaves some unanswered gaps in the film but I just think that the strength of the opening scene at night and the music just sets the pace for the whole film. When I watch the daytime version I just don't get that immediate impact and expectancy. I also just can't get over Cleon's dodgy hairstyle and think he should not be seen without his head scarf/piece. I also don't like the music that is played when the Warriors walk away as this music dates the film.
I'm interested to know what the film would have been like if they had stuck to the scripted version but for me I still think having the film start at night and immediately seeing some of the other gangs plus listening to the Warriors in pairs talking about the conclave was just the perfect start to a classic film.
What do you think???