Page 1 of 2

Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 3:40 am
by $now4Ever
Do you guys think Cowboy played Cowboy really well or do you think Robert Diniro would have done a better job. In my oppinion i think it's good how it is but always wondered what the movie would of been like with Robert Diniro.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 3:43 am
by Cowboy Is Cool
Well, Tom McKitterick played Cowboy perfectly, in my opinion. It's a shame he never acted again. But, watching Taxi Driver, I think DeNiro could have pulled it off. He sure as hell can act good, but as Cowboy? I dunno. It would have been interesting, to say the least.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 3:50 am
by $now4Ever
Yeah i couldnt really see him playin Cowboy nowa days.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 3:55 am
by Cowboy Is Cool
When I first found out about how DeNiro could have played him, I thought: What, he's too old!

Image

But I forgot that back then, he looked like this:

Image

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 4:17 am
by Lion
Naahh, I think Tom did a good job.  DeNiro would of taken the focus away from the other characters, therefor making the film lose value.  I am glad they decided to keep Tom M. 

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 7:39 pm
by eliminator1
Not knocking him as an actor, but even in the 70's De Niro would have been too old to be playing a teen gang member. Plus it doesn't make sense to have a big star play one of the smaller role Warriors.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 7:40 pm
by Cowboy Is Cool
eliminator1 wrote: Not knocking him as an actor, but even in the 70's De Niro would have been too old to be playing a teen gang member. Plus it doesn't make sense to have a big star play one of the smaller role Warriors.
If DeNiro did play Cowboy, they would have expanded his role. No way would they make a big name actor a minor star in a low-budget movie.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 16, 2007 9:12 pm
by Swan 1979
I think that Tom did a great job and really brung something to the cowboy character.Anyway tom ending up playing cowboy and did a great job so im happy.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Fri Jul 20, 2007 7:14 pm
by playaAjax15
I think that Tom did a great job playing cowboy. I am glad they decided to keep Tom M.  :D

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 23, 2007 5:07 am
by Wheeljak
Why stop with Cowboy? Why not recast the movie with well-known, established actors? I say cast Charlton Heston, Orson Welles, and Robert Duvall! :roll:

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 23, 2007 5:09 am
by Cowboy Is Cool
Wheeljak wrote: Why stop with Cowboy? Why not recast the movie with well-known, established actors? I say cast Charlton Heston, Orson Welles, and Robert Duvall! :roll:
Um... just so you know, Robert DeNiro really WAS going to be Cowboy. We didn't make this up.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 23, 2007 5:22 am
by Wheeljak
Cowboy Is Cool wrote:
Wheeljak wrote: Why stop with Cowboy? Why not recast the movie with well-known, established actors? I say cast Charlton Heston, Orson Welles, and Robert Duvall! :roll:
Um... just so you know, Robert DeNiro really WAS going to be Cowboy. We didn't make this up.
No offense, but I find this quite suspect. First of all, the movie would not likely have drawn an Oscar-winning actor. Although it has a good script, let's be honest-- "The Warriors" doesn't have the weight of scripts like The Godfather and Taxi Driver. Second of all, I read somewhere that Walter Hill specifically wanted to cast fresh faces for the movie. Third, as others have said, he was too old for the part. Deniro was already in his late 30s in the late seventies; way too old to play a teenager. Unless I see proof, I will regard this as nothing more than a tall tale, on par with the story that the scream heard in the Ohio Players song "Love Rollercoaster" is a woman getting stabbed.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 23, 2007 5:23 am
by Cowboy Is Cool
No, maybe I said it wrong. They asked him to be in it. He refused, for obvious reasons.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Mon Jul 23, 2007 9:03 am
by Swan 1979
Wheeljak wrote:
Cowboy Is Cool wrote:
Wheeljak wrote: Why stop with Cowboy? Why not recast the movie with well-known, established actors? I say cast Charlton Heston, Orson Welles, and Robert Duvall! :roll:
Um... just so you know, Robert DeNiro really WAS going to be Cowboy. We didn't make this up.
No offense, but I find this quite suspect. First of all, the movie would not likely have drawn an Oscar-winning actor. Although it has a good script, let's be honest-- "The Warriors" doesn't have the weight of scripts like The Godfather and Taxi Driver. Second of all, I read somewhere that Walter Hill specifically wanted to cast fresh faces for the movie. Third, as others have said, he was too old for the part. Deniro was already in his late 30s in the late seventies; way too old to play a teenager. Unless I see proof, I will regard this as nothing more than a tall tale, on par with the story that the scream heard in the Ohio Players song "Love Rollercoaster" is a woman getting stabbed.
Are no mate Cowboy Is Cool is right you can look at any warriors articles on wikipedia or the warriors site  Robert Deniro was asked to star in the film but rejected the offer for unknown reasons maybe because it wasn't a big budget movie who knows but the point is Cowboy is Cool is right Deniro was gonna play cowboy.

Re: Robert Diniro or Cowboy?

Posted: Sat Jul 28, 2007 7:32 am
by Vermin Is Cool
Swan 1979 wrote:
Wheeljak wrote:
Cowboy Is Cool wrote: Um... just so you know, Robert DeNiro really WAS going to be Cowboy. We didn't make this up.
No offense, but I find this quite suspect. First of all, the movie would not likely have drawn an Oscar-winning actor. Although it has a good script, let's be honest-- "The Warriors" doesn't have the weight of scripts like The Godfather and Taxi Driver. Second of all, I read somewhere that Walter Hill specifically wanted to cast fresh faces for the movie. Third, as others have said, he was too old for the part. Deniro was already in his late 30s in the late seventies; way too old to play a teenager. Unless I see proof, I will regard this as nothing more than a tall tale, on par with the story that the scream heard in the Ohio Players song "Love Rollercoaster" is a woman getting stabbed.
Are no mate Cowboy Is Cool is right you can look at any warriors articles on wikipedia or the warriors site  Robert Deniro was asked to star in the film but rejected the offer for unknown reasons maybe because it wasn't a big budget movie who knows but the point is Cowboy is Cool is right Deniro was gonna play cowboy.
They're both right. And besides, if you were a true Warriors fan, you would've known that.