book or film?

[swift eyed wolf]

hello warriors! ive not read the book yet...just ordered it from america
very excited .

im wondering how good you guys and ladies think the book is?

think carefully

[Tantive7]

The Film ,definitely!!!
Hell the book is good too!!!

[BTW A.K.A the killer household appliance]

QUESTION what are the gang members names in the book, i think theres lunkface,juniper and razor but thats all i know.

[SoldierHeavyMuscle]

man, are you gonna be bummed!!!
if you wanna READ the warriors, a book version of the warriors so to speak, read the original script!!!

[The Fox]

man, are you gonna be bummed!!!
if you wanna READ the warriors, a book version of the warriors so to speak, read the original script!!!

That's for sure. The script is a real page turner.

The book is a little bit of a let down. More because it's not the film!

[Ranchgal]

QUESTION what are the gang members names in the book, i think theres lunkface,juniper and razor but thats all i know.

book .............(movie)
Papa Arnold (Cleon)
Hector (Swan)
Lunkface (Ajax)
The Junior
Dewy
Hinton; was the artist
Bimbo ; was the bearer, he also had the alcohol flask (vermin)??

Ishmael leader of biggest gang--(Cyrus)

there is a thread where we went through this at length--the book is much slower, the characters very unaware, and more senslessly violent, than the movie.

[The Rogue]

it was the biggest peice of junk ive ever purchased. the charachters arent the same and the events arent either. i love the warriors so i forced myself to read it but it SUCKED

[PadLock]

I just finished it for a 2nd time last night. and i must say it was alot better. there are sceens from the movie that are right out of the book. but its much more of a drama. i like how the gang ages mix from 14 to 18. i like how they show what being in a gang and how hard it is. The movie kind of makes it look cool.

Dewy: I really see Vermin just because he's kind of a slacker, a funny one, it seems at times he doesnt care at all, but then he does,

Hinton: i can see parts of swan in him,

Bimbo: Kind of like the fox, 3rd in charge, followed Hector.

[Harley]

You can't really say the movie and the book can be compared because taken separatly they are too different. Like PadLock said, some of the scenes are taken right out of the book, and it gives an idea on which the movie story was based from, but the book and movie have two different moods.

The book shows a more dirty and desparate situation, and the characters are written in a way that you aren't really rooting for them like the ones in the movie, more the book is showing how things work within the gang and what drives certain characters to do what they do.

The movie shows (at least the Swan character) characters put in a situation and they either have to adapt to survive or die, you don't really see the Warriors doing anything that makes you hate them. There also is a clear and definate feel of an ending, which isn't as clear in the book. The book is like just taking a day out of their lives but the movie is like a story with a begining, middle, and end.

I have to look at the two separately and say that both are good in their own ways.

[swift eyed wolf]

man, are you gonna be bummed!!!
if you wanna READ the warriors, a book version of the warriors so to speak, read the original script!!!

good idea... #-o why did i never think of that ](*,)

[bushnut]

I read the book last year and was quite dissapointed. It wasn't a bad read but doesn't bear much resemblence to the movie. It's a bit too fururistic for my liking. The script does look class but my printer is bust and i've only read parts of it on my laptop which doesn't do anything for my eyes and leaves me with a migraine. time to get a new printer sorted and start at the beginning.

[Goose]

I have never read the book but its a shame to see people say its abit pony when it is the original source material.

[Ranchgal]

I have never read the book but its a shame to see people say its abit pony when it is the original source material.

Original source material is a LONG WAY from the finished product, and I don't mind stating my opinion about how slow the book was in comparision to the movie at all. The book may have been a base, but it was so far removed from the original script or the movie we see-one really has very little to do with the other.
Actually only the Title, and the basic concept about a CI gang a long way from home is the same. two totally different stories.
The book is a totally different story than the movie, and the movie is VERY VERY different from the original screen script.

I am glad I have read all three--but the book would NOT have made a decent movie as written, and the original script would have changed the dynamics so much it wouldn't have been as good on film either.

[swift eyed wolf]

even though the general consensus is that the book is a bit naff, im still looking forward to it!

the script was a good read! cheers shm for putting that up!

i just like to learn a little more about the lifestyle and characters etc!